This post is a break from the norm and relates to my other main relaxation outlet, books.
If I’m too tired to grab a camera and pop out for a photowalk, my next chill, is getting into a book. I’m not one to sit in front of the TV and vegitate, I’m bookish.
Its been 12 months today, since my dear mum passed away on 8th December 2023, which to me will bring a more solemn meaning to xmas now. Ahead of the family scattering the ashes tomorrow, I have reflected on the last 12 months and realised that I have spent the best part of this year, reminisicsing, laughing and crying. I have also made a concerted effort to get closer to my mums irish heritage.
This leads me to Patrick Radden Keefe's "Say Nothing: A True Story of Murder and Memory in Northern Ireland" is a masterclass in storytelling, taking readers on a harrowing journey through the heart of the Troubles, a book that I finished reading last week.
This 2019 publication has been such a overwhelming success, it's been lauded by everyone. To such an extent, its now been made into a 9 part documentary, which can be viewed here in the UK on Disney+.
I’ve not avoided it per se, but I stayed away, for nothing else but not to be carried away in the sweeping public opinion of this being an excellent read, how foolish was I?
It's aimed at both the novice and also those well informed, requiring a brush up on salient points in history.
I’m not one to self profess being an ‘expert’ on Northern Ireland or indeed 'The Troubles’. But I do consider myself well informed as I've read a variety of books on this period of history, since my mid teens, to get a better understanding on what is also known as the ‘Dirty War’. Relating to the tactics used both by the British army / intelligence services and the terrorist organisations on both side of the divide. I thought it was time to belatedly see what all the fuss was about.
In this interview with the author, Radden Keefe,
explains the inspiration for the book title, bring this Seamus Heaney poem.
This most certainly isn't a party political broadcast, nor is it intended to offend any readers who are directly or indirectly affected by this period of time. It's just something that I have great interest in.
My interest is now not only the written form but also the photographic form, having recently discovered the Belfast Archive Project.
This is an excellent representation of all sides of the community and something that I think the reader would enjoy, its an excellent reportage photo archive.
The question is, is the book better than the documentary? How does this powerful narrative translate across different mediums? Is the book superior to the TV adaptation, or does the photography archive offer a unique perspective? Let's explore.
The Book: A Deep Dive into the Shadows
The book format allows Keefe to delve deep into the complexities of the conflict, weaving together the personal stories of victims and perpetrators. His meticulous research and engaging prose bring the characters to life, painting a vivid picture of a society torn apart by violence. The book format offers the reader time and space to contemplate the moral ambiguities and lingering questions raised by the Troubles.
The TV Series: A Visual Spectacle
The TV adaptation of "Say Nothing" is a visually stunning production, bringing the story to life with gripping performances and atmospheric cinematography. The series format allows for a more expansive narrative, exploring additional subplots and characters. However, some viewers may find the pacing slower than the book, and the adaptation may sacrifice some of the book's nuance for dramatic effect.
The Photography Archive: A Glimpse into History
The photography archive offers a unique perspective on the Troubles, capturing the raw emotion and brutality of the conflict. The images, often taken by amateur photographers, provide a powerful and unfiltered record of the events. However, the archive lacks the narrative structure and context provided by the book and the TV series.
The Verdict: Which Medium Reigns Supreme?
Ultimately, the best medium for experiencing "Say Nothing" depends on your individual preferences. If you prefer a deep, immersive reading experience, the book is the way to go. If you enjoy the visual spectacle of a well-crafted TV series, the adaptation is a compelling choice. And if you're interested in a raw and unfiltered look at the Troubles, the photography archive offers a unique perspective.
No matter which medium you choose, "Say Nothing" is a powerful and thought-provoking exploration of one of the most complex and tragic periods in modern history.
Until next time, keep reading and watching.